Ubuntu: Week One
Ya, I know. It's been quite a while since my last post. Things have been incredibly busy with work, and I am also getting married in October. Needless to say, I've had little time to post anything here.
Anyway, a couple of weeks ago I decided to give Linux as a desktop OS another chance. I've been using Linux as a server for a number of years and I do like it overall. Like any OS, it has it's downsides and upsides, but overall it's been reliable and smooth. However, my past experiences with Linux as a desktop haven't been very successful. Running my own business requires me to use certain software, as well as ensure that my productivity level remains high. Unfortunately, that's never been a strong point of Linux as a desktop.I only use my laptop for presentations and travel, so i figured this would be a great way to run Ubuntu through it's paces. Initially, I used the LiveCD of Ubuntu 8.04. I was immediately impressed to see that the desktop itself was much nicer than any other Linux flavor I had ever used. I played around with it for a couple of days and was impressed enough to install it.My first thought was to run XP & Ubuntu as dual boot, since this was supposed to be a supported configuration. Unfortunately, Ubuntu didn't like the way the disk was partitioned and failed here. I didn't really have the time (or inclination) to sort through the logs to find out why, so I settled on starting with a fresh install of Ubuntu.The install process was smooth and also found all my devices. This was a pleasant surprise! The install seemed to take about the same length of time as WIndows XP.Overall Linux seemed to be a fairly good replacement for XP. The apps I normally used were available or there was an OSS equivalent: FireFox, Office suite, RDP Client, Collaboration client (email, calendaring, tasks, contacts, etc).Evolution, the default email client, seemed to work very well as an Outlook replacement, even utilizing Exchange over HTTP. I was a bit disappointed by the lack of client-side spam filtering, especially since it meant I would likely have to do a spam assassin installtion of some sort, which is always frustrating.There are a few things which have bugged me:1. Crashes. Sometimes it just plan crashes to the CLI. No error, nothing. Other times it has decided to just shut down. No indication as to why. I was at a conference so I have yet had the opportunity to investigate why. This happens multiple times per day, doing ordinary tasks such as web browsing or checking email. It just doesn't seem to be very stable.2. Installations suck (still). Seriously, I was hoping this would have been figured out by now. Although I can, I have no desire to sit down and do long, drawn out installations via the CLI. The majority of the software I wanted to install was available via the package manager, which was nice. However, some apps were not and I was forced to go through the whole extraction and manual installation process, as well as resolving dependencies. This is very unproductive. Overall, I'd say it took me, easily, 5x longer to configure Ubuntu than XP. I'll concede to a lack of experience being a major factor in this, but some things, like Eclipse, shouldnt take 2-3 hours to install and configure.3. Performance. I am running Ubuntu 64 (Hardy). I would expect the performance to be considerably better than XP 32 bit. I found this to be quite the opposite. Windows are slow to open, Evolution sometimes becomes unresponsive for up to a minute at a time. Other apps, including Firefox, tend to be sluggish at times as well.4. I hear so many people complaining about User Account Control in Windows Vista. Yet, my experience on Ubuntu hasn't been much different. Anytime I want to change my configuration or do any administrative tasks I get prompted for my password. Yes, I realize it needs to sudo to perform these tasks, and i completely ok and even agree with this. But, why the hell are people bitching about Vista when Ubuntu does nearly the EXACT SAME THING? I'm boggled.5. The UI has a long way to go. It reminds me of Windows 95 in a way, crude and unpolished. I hope some real designers help implement a theme someday that can compare with the OS X or Vista UI.All this said, I think I will continue to use Ubuntu. It seems capable of doing what I need it to do, and with some tweaking and R&D I am certain I can resolve most of these issues myself. I can't see myself replacing my Vista 64 desktop with Ubuntu anytime soon, though.


